5 Replies Latest reply: Jan 27, 2014 11:57 AM by Khorn RSS

Common Core Stumbling Blocks

Khorn Novice
Currently Being Moderated

I need all of you who have been working with and teaching about the conversion to the CCSS to help me understand the dilemma?  Now that the Colorado mothers are filing a Bill in the CO legislature to delay the adoption of the CCSS, I am having difficulty getting my head around the problems. I thought that by definition a set of "common" standards was set and each school and each district could exceed those standards by merely enhancing their own curricula's.

 

Is there a total misconception by the public on what these new "common" standards are intended to do?  Or, am I totally off base in my thinking?   I could use some enlightenment from all of you who are experts in this CCSS concept.  Below is an excerpt from the CO mothers who have found a voice in their legislature.  When I read this, I was really confused. The assumption would seem to be that if a school is exceeding these "common" standards, then they would have to already be teaching those basics. So, if that's the case, I say what is the big issue? Schools still have control over their curricula's.

 

"We are concerned because Common Core brings the standards to the middle, lifting some schools and lowering others. If a school is already outperforming with its current standards, it still has to teach Common Core's lower standards in order to pass the test to which everything is tied.  These standards are copyrighted and cannot be exceeded or changed more than 15%. It is hard to achieve greatness while staying within 15% of mediocrity. Colorado, along with so many others, took the Race to the Top bribe money to adopt Common Core, even before the standards were fully written and neither parents nor legislators were asked to vote on this."

  • Re: Common Core Stumbling Blocks
    Jane Brown Master
    Currently Being Moderated

    Perhaps this is the blog ("Colorado Moms Push Bill to Delay Common Core") you were reading and perhaps it was another article as it has made the news.


    There are many Myths and Misconceptions that parents hold as truths:

    • They want every kid in the country doing the same lesson on the same day.
    • Common Core Standards will "dumb down" the more rigorous curriculum in the better schools.
    • Common Core Standard are too rigorous and students will score lower on college entrance tests.

    And I'm sure you all have more.

     

    What can we do to explain Common Core to parents?

    • Listen to their concerns and build trust.
    • Explain as best you can how Common Core Standards are being met in your classroom.
    • Help parents see how their children are improving. Learning is more than a single national test score.
    • Share national data and help parents know this is a movement across the United States, not just their own state.
    • Offer the opportunity for parents to try a sample, grade appropriate, set of test questions given on the computer. Look for sample information to share with parents so they understand where we are headed and why.

    It is all about educating our parents as well as our students.

    • Re: Common Core Stumbling Blocks
      Khorn Novice
      Currently Being Moderated

      Jane:

      Thank you for that thoughtful response.  I apologize for not citing my source. It was the recent edition of Education Week (Teacher Section.) But you were correct... it was a Blog  I got caught up with the Title and didn't check to see if it was a Blog.  My bad. 

       

      But, my concern is still the same about the myths and misleading information that is floating around about CCSS.  I just wanted to make sure I had my ducks lined up correctly for my discussions of rebuttal in this state.

       

      I checked out your link to the sample test questions, and I certainly applaud the level of thinking that has been created in the design. 

  • Re: Common Core Stumbling Blocks
    Jeanne Rogers Apprentice
    Currently Being Moderated

    It seems that there is still misunderstanding associated with the Common Core, but mainly with its implementation.  Originally the idea of a set of national standards was applauded.  Then when it came to implementing them, there was a realization that to be successful teaching methods needed to change.

     

    Money was sought after from the federal government's Race to the Top.  When awarded funds, some states found that they had to strictly follow the guidelines set by the federal government.  State officials felt they were "giving up control" of varied facets of education policy. Local school districts began wondering why the change when their "state" was performing well. Now there are states "changing" the standards to meet their needs better. Florida is one state considering 56+ changes. It is possible that the initial rational for the common standards has been affected by political input.

     

    We have additional discussions in the community that may offer insight:

    Do Common Core Standards address common sense needs?

    What would you tell parents about the Common Core State Standards (CCSS)?

    Are you succeeding with Common Core?

  • Re: Common Core Stumbling Blocks
    Lynne Hoffman Apprentice
    Currently Being Moderated

    Hi Karen,

    Jeanne has referenced some additional good discussions on the Common Core Standards located in the Thinkfinity Community.  This is such an important topic in education that we have an open group devoted to this issue.  We invite all Community members to join our Common Core group and share their thoughts on this timely topic.


    Thanks for sharing your discussion on the Education Week blog and making others aware of the ongoing dilemma on this topic that concerns educators, parents, and students.


    Lynne

    • Re: Common Core Stumbling Blocks
      Khorn Novice
      Currently Being Moderated

      Jeanne and Lynne:

      Thank you for the additional input.  Of course, Jeanne's very tactful way of stating that when the federal government offers money, there are always strings.  Those strings are the issues involved with what was initially a great way for all states to be on the same page. The "puppeteer" always wants to be in control and that explanation is the driving force now.  What a shame.

       

      Reminds me when I was working on a grant team that had received $9.2 million Challenge Grant. Talk about being pulled by the strings.

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...